So simple a beginning: the Origin of Species at 150 years is an experimental collaboration between academics and science writers with the goal of producing a set of commentaries in a blog-like format on each of the chapters in Charles Darwin's landmark 1859 book.
http://sosimpleabeginning.com : http://bloggingdarwin.com
venta viagra capital federal generico viagra españa viagra generique belgique cialis ou acheter viagra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra en suisse viagra chez la femme levitra 20mg generique viagra riddim comprar levitra 20 mg cialis quebec cialis generique achat vrai viagra en ligne comprar viagra cialis forum viagra pour femme le viagra viagra türkei rezeptfrei prix cialis 20mg viagra vente libre belgique compro cialis tadalafil achat cialis generico 20 mg cialis authentique acheter cialis moins cher achat viagra luxembourg viagra andorre acheter cialis 5mg viagra holland ohne rezept achat viagra en suisse viagra des femmes kamagra deutschland kamagra versand prix cialis en france levitra pas cher viagra sans ordonnance levitra madrid viagra ohne rezept holland farmacias viagra acheter cialis 5 milligrams super kamagra online bestellen forum viagra generique commander viagra kamagra preise kamagra indien viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung cialis inde levitra donde comprar viagra 50mg ohne rezept super kamagra online kaufen achat viagra france viagra 50 mg forum viagra internet viagra pharmacie france viagra frankreich rezeptfrei cialis marca achat viagra generique acheter viagra sur la net viagra torte rezept kamagra sicher kaufen kamagra kaufen günstig cialis generique france viagra authentique cialis le vrai levitra achat levitra venta cialis en ligne prix du cialis precio cialis 5 mg 28 comprimidos cialis en españa viagra se vende sin receta cialise medicament prix cialis belgique kamagra online apotheke achat tadalafil comprar viagra barcelona vente de viagra sur internet pilule viagra pour femme levitra 20 mg precio viagra venta sin receta tadalafil generico mexico kamagra gel kaufen viagra rezept bekommen levitra sin receta medica veritable viagra günstig kamagra kaufen viagra a vendre procurer du cialis levitra medicament cialis incompatibilidades comprar viagra por internet venta viagra online super kamagra billig viagra au quebec prix cialis france forum viagra en ligne achat de cialis tadalafil similares pastilla levitra venta tadalafil sildenafil pour femme acheter viagra 20mg rezeptpflichtig viagra cialis ventajas viagra belgique viagra génériques precio viagra en farmacia kamagra rezept viagra sin receta en farmacias kamagra foro acheter viagra paris precio viagra españa levitra comprar viagra 50mg rezeptfrei viagra sin receta cialis niederlande viagra se puede comprar sin receta cialis marketing strategy tadalafil colombia acheter cialis viagra femme viagra cialis requiere receta medica kamagra in apotheke opiniones cialis generico cialis farmacia ahumada cialis sans ordonnance belgique cialis generico opiniones compra levitra comprar viagra con paypal precio viagra generico cialis 10 mg precio forum generique cialis cialis 5 mg precio kamagra österreich viagra effet secondaire cialis livraison rapide kamagra kaufen deutschland cialis generique prix prix de cialis achat viagra montreal kamagra verschreibungspflichtig comprar cialis levitra sur le net comprar viagra generica en españa viagra prix ventajas viagra cialis ca marche viagra cialis rezeptfrei comprar cialis por telefono venta de cialis levitra foro viagra reseller cialis presentacion y precio pilule cialis viagra ventas original viagra ohne rezept cialis 20mg belgique viagra donde comprar cialis medicamento vente cialis en ligne cialis temoignage comprar tadalafil mejor viagra o cialis venta viagra viagras comprar viagra quebec precio viagra farmacia precios viagra cialis levitra prix levitra pharmacie cialis sur ordonnance prix viagra 100 generique viagra prix vente de cialis günstig kamagra bestellen kamagra gel viagra generica españa generique cialis cialis seguridad social procurer du viagra kamagra 100mg kaufen medicamento levitra kamagra kautabletten erfahrungen comprar levitra sin receta prix sildenafil vente cialis france venta cialis viagra ohne rezept forum precio viagra argentina achat viagra en ligne venta cialis generico cialis a vendre viagra 25 mg rezeptfrei cialis holland rezeptfrei impuissance sexuelle viagra receta medica tarif cialis pharmacie cialis vrai cialis comprimidos genericos viagra cialis pharmacie paris precios viagra cialis holland levitra sans ordonnance prix cialis 10 mg cialis generico venta comprar levitra generico viagra requiere receta medica achat viagra internet tarif viagra pharmacie cialis generico foro cialis comprar online comprar generico viagra cialis generico en farmacias firmel levitra acheter viagra en belgique super kamagra billig kaufen acheter cialis paris pilule viagra effet cialis sur femme comprar viagra natural acheter viagra pour femme viagra rezeptfrei wo levitra precio farmacia cialis pour la femme viagra rezeptpflicht holland viagra viagra generica funciona prix viagra cialis vente libre kamagra günstig acheter viagra pas chere pastillas cialis comprar cialis españa kamagra pillen achat viagra belgique achat viagra en france cialis farmacias similares vendo viagra santiago cialis prix kamagra para mujeres viagra comprar online viagra barata vardenafil generique cialis prix belgique viagra a andorre cialis thailande viagra se compra con receta viagra en pharmacie prix viagra prix en france viagra generique sildenafil generique viagra rezeptfrei holland test viagra rezeptfrei levitra en suisse kamagra oral jelly billig tadalafil comprimidos medicament cialis 20mg cialis necesita receta commander viagra en ligne comprar cialis barato cialis comprar españa foro tadalafil vrai cialis moins cher super kamagra preis rezept viagra cialis diario precio viagra 50 mg precio cialis lilly icos viagra pharmacie generique cialis 5mg comprar cialis por internet precio cialis en farmacia viagra espagne prix levitra 20mg precio cialis farmacia precio viagra en españa venta viagra farmacias acheter cialis forum viagra generique pharmacie acheter cialis en espagne levitra bayer precio medicamento viagra comprar viagra en farmacia viagra generico sildenafil cialis rezeptfrei holland acheter cialis sans ordonnance achat viagra sur internet kamagra en venezuela levitra 10 mg precio viagra in holland kaufen tabletas cialis tarif cialis 20mg viagra livraison 24h viagra es de venta libre precio cialis cialis se vende en farmacias similares tadalafil commander du viagra impuissance erection viagra barcelona comprar viagra farmacia levitra similares viagra receta cialis foro cialis ordonnance super kamagra kaufen levitra en farmacias del ahorro viagra compra online comprar viagra barata comprar viagra buenos aires viagra rezeptfrei frankreich cialis o viagra cual es mejor holland cialis holland viagra kaufen acheter viagra en ligne forum comprar viagra por correo generique cialis 20mg remboursement cialis acheter viagra internet acheter cialis sur internet acheter cialis en suisse cialis meilleur prix cialis de 5 mg viagra veritable kamagra billig viagra nur auf rezept medicament viagra levitra farmacias del ahorro viagra remboursement vendo viagra barcelona viagra prix officiel cialis 20mg cialis genericos cialis receta medica viagra generique sildenafil levitra tabletas kamagra oral jelly wo kaufen generique cialis 10mg andorre viagra cialis internet kamagra 100 mg viagra im internet kaufen levitra moins cher pastillas levitra cialis se vende con receta cialis prix de vente precio levitra generico commande viagra vendo viagra antofagasta tadalafil pas cher cialis 10mg viagras prix

Ship’s Naturalist? Oh, Really?

Tom Levenson

Welcome to So Simple A Beginning’s simple beginning.

Charles Darwin in 1840.
Charles Darwin in an 1840 portrait, only a few years after returning from his time on the HMS Beagle.

As described in the “Welcome” post (and on our About page), this is the start of what will be a roughly year-long effort to produce a new, crowd/cloud sourced commentary on the most important book about science published since 1687: Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species.

The Origin, of course, celebrates its 150th anniversary later this year, and I and the rest of the folks here are taking this bit of numerology as the opportunity to read and react to this foundational text with as nearly new eyes as we can.

We want you to help too: read, respond, write. When it’s all done, if this works as well as it could and should, we will have a jointly built a web of ideas and knowledge surrounding Charles’s original construction — one which can continue to accrete as long as people want to wrestle with the extraordinary transformation that Mr. Darwin set in motion.

So that said, lets begin at the beginning. I’m going to offer a pair of short posts today and tomorrow — dipping our collective toe into the water — on a couple of facets of the introduction to The Origin. The first one, below, considers the lie with which Darwin begins his book of revelation. The second will explain the significance of the year 1687 for any assessment of Darwin and his book.

Over the next few days, you’ll see a couple more posts on the introduction: one by John Durant, director of the MIT Museum, on Darwin’s carefully chosen epigraphs, and the other by Evo-Devo’s and the University of Wisconsin’s Sean Carroll, still aglow from his January trip to England to handle the actual notebooks in which Darwin recorded the prehistory of The Origin. After that, it’ll be on to Chapter One and off to the races.


Enough preamble: Let’s start to look at the way Darwin tried to ease his audience into the radical notions to come.

HMS Beagle in 1841, watercolor by Owen Stanley.
The HMS Beagle in 1841, watercolor by Owen Stanley.

So, just to get this out of the way: Darwin’s great book begins with a truthful lie. He writes, line one, first up: “When on board H.M.S. ‘Beagle’ as naturalist…”

The truth: he functioned as ship’s naturalist throughout the voyage, collecting and analyzing as he went. He worked in close quarters — and usually comfortable collegiality — with the naval natural historians amongst the rest of the Beagle’s crew, including his captain, Robert Fitzroy, the other officers, and even the captain’s steward and the ship’s clerk. Within the first few months of the five year expedition, Darwin had become the central locus of all the biology and geology to be done in and amongst the naval surveying that was the official job for the voyage. There is no doubt — and no lie in the claim — that he was the chief investigator of the natural world on the Beagle for the entire five year journey.

But in fact, Darwin was not enrolled on the Beagle’s muster as its naturalist. That function on Royal Navy vessels whose duty permitted such efforts was usually performed by the ship’s surgeon. On the Beagle, that would have been Dr. Robert McCormick who fully expected to have the opportunity to build his collection at each Beagle port of call. Darwin himself was a private gentleman, the captain’s guest and dinner companion, nothing more.

Captain Robert FitzRoy, 1836.
Captain Robert FitzRoy, in 1836, the year the HMS Beagle returned to England.

McCormick did not last long; frozen out by Fitzroy, and faced with the sight of Darwin’s collecting apparatus where his should have had first dibs, he quarreled with his captain and took passage home from Rio de Janiero just four months into the voyage. For a detailed account of the whole episode, see Janet Browne’s Charles Darwin: Voyaging, pp. 191-210.

As Browne points out, at least part of the significance of this episode is the glimpse it gives of the web of connections and social hierarchies in which Darwin worked. To put it another way: the world of science in which Darwin lived mapped onto nineteenth century British society in complicated ways. It’s a cartoon to say that Darwin had the good fortune to be born into the right kind of family for genteel inquiry in Britain in the 1830s and that McCormick did not. But it is true that Fitzroy expressly required a class connection to the companion he sought to keep him sane on the long journey. The county-bred, well-to-do Darwin met that requirement and the middle-class McCormick did not.

Such simple minded pigeonholing is not the whole story, nor even perhaps most of it. The specifics of personality matter, especially in any place so confined as vessel just ninety feet long. McCormick was not the easiest person to love, prickly about position and prerogatives, and he could well have fallen out with Fitzroy with or without Darwin on the scene.

Charles Darwin, 1869.
The sage of Down House: Darwin’s later, iconic appearance.

But still, Charles Darwin became the Beagle’s de-facto naturalist after displacing another man as ambitious as himself. He shed no tears for McCormick, and before and after the doctor left the voyage, Darwin pursued his own naturalization with no sense of deferring to the “official” naturalist on board. As Darwin aged, and then after he died, the image of the retiring, self-effacing sage of Down House — that old man with the heroic beard — forms the iconic portrait of the founder of modern biology. The Origin was not written by that man—or better, that caricture.

Darwin was — not ruthless, so much — but relentlessly focused on the task of gathering what he wanted to know about nature. He would seek out and gladly use whatever he could coax from correspondents, and, at least as a young man, as McCormick learned he was cheerfully prepared use whatever advantages he had to ensure his access to the natural history treasures he sought.

And the relevance of all this to reading The Origin: Don’t be fooled. Darwin is a tough man, a tough thinker, and someone prepared for the fight over facts and their meaning that will play out over the rest of the book.

One Response to “Ship’s Naturalist? Oh, Really?”

  1. [...] Darwin was not brought aboard HMS Beagle as ship’s naturalist but rather as a gentleman companion for Captain Robert Fitzroy. Read more about it at So Simple A Beginning. [...]